2016, Jan - Feb
VW's Game Plan
by Cliff Leppke
What’s VW’s next move in the emissions scandal?
One of my family’s year-end rituals: playing board games. From childhood through adulthood, my parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles invited me to play games. It was fun, an initiation into how to follow the rules and work with others. Some games are pure luck, good sportsmanship a key virtue. Others involve deft collaboration or skillful maneuvers. This playful and sometime downright serious pastime—my parents will dock me if I don’t discard while playing Sequence—is one way we create a sense of community, a sense of family.
As the holidays approached, I wondered which of my winter pastimes best fit the VW story during 2015. Until mid-year, Monopoly, Risk or Chess seemed to express VW’s world—the one-time small-car company had grown into an international powerhouse set on snatching Toyota’s seat on the throne. And it accomplished that despite soft sales in the USA. Things change.
VW’s car on the road of Life took a detour into an uncharted territory that revealed serious troubles with VW’s so-called clean diesel engines and the management of the people who designed, built and marketed its vehicles. Some thought VW’s pollution problem was a minor quibble. VW would regroup (lose a turn), while others spun their wheels. That wasn’t in the cards. Instead it became Trivial Pursuit. VW fumbled key questions. It tried Sorry, but its bell didn’t ring. Now, it’s Aggravation: will VW do the right things?
Since VW’s game plan in the auto business has shifted gears, I thought I’d present VW’s lineup of players and pieces in a manner that makes sense of the firm’s fate.
But first, I must report that the automotive trades say VW of America finally did something smart. In a game-changing move, it retained Kenneth Feinberg to design and administer an independent claims resolution for owners of 2.0-liter and 3.0-liter TDIs.
Feinberg, who oversaw the compensation program for victims of General Motors’ defective ignition switches, anticipates a “menu of remedies.” He’s become the man with the plan when it comes to settling high-profile cases. He also oversaw compensation programs for victims of the 9/11 terrorist attacks and the 2010 BP Deepwater oil spill. VW says it wants to satisfy affected owners while avoiding protracted litigation. At this moment, Feinberg believes remedies will be attractive enough, the equivalent of legal litigation. And everything is on the table, including vehicle buy backs.
•EXECUTIVE BOARD SHUFFLE: OPERATION, RISK or SORRY?: Volkswagen’s management and supervisory boards shuffled their decks; found new players. If this were a board game, it’s not Candy Land. The two top players (see below) are VWAG insiders with Porsche connections. Will they dial 911? Their challenge: remake VW’s management structure and mission and then ditch those who were criticized for hierarchal behavior, brand elitism and large egos. The game: win confidence with a change VW’s organizational structure. Forbes magazine is skeptical; VW’s management includes people tainted by their connections to those who created the EA 189 engine or other scandals. One such person, says Forbes, is the firm’s new compliance officer, Francisco Javier Garcia Sanz. Ouch!
VW’s new look is supposedly symbolized by an emphasis on corporate compliance and integrity. For example, VW announced the appointment of Michael Steiner (Porsche quality czar) as group compliance commissioner. He handles VW’s worldwide discussions with global regulatory authorities. Steiner reports to VWAG Board CEO Matthias Mueller. Coming soon: Christine Hohmann-Dennhardt (Mercedes), who will also report to Mueller. She will be board member for integrity and legal affairs. These leaders, Mueller says, are on par with sales, research and development. Not a believer? Christian Klingler, board manager responsible for sales and marketing, exited shortly after Martin Winterkorn resigned due to disagreements with VW’s management board.
Here is an incomplete look at VWAG’s managerial lineup:
Top Job: Hans Dieter Poetsch, chairman of VW’s Supervisors Board (fills Ferdinand Piech’s spot vacated last spring during the failed Winterkorn ouster). Second fiddle: VW’s CEO: Matthias Mueller, chairman of VW’s Board of Management. His managerial team: Herbert Diess handles VW cars (new guy from BMW). Audi’s Rupert Stadler retains his chair, and Frank Witter is the finance chief or, CFO. This is the short list.
Seat, Skoda and other VW brands have their own managers too. Farther down the metaphorical corporate ladder is Skoda’s Frank Welsch, who became VW’s new head of technical development. Former engineering big shots were suspended or resigned, so someone must move up. VW will simplify its corporate structure, paring costs and making it more responsive to local markets. It’s not certain whether it will have the resources to regain a toehold in North America.
On Dec. 17, VW announced five new leaders for development, sales, design and production:
• Ulrich Eichhorn: Leads R&D, replaces Ulrich Hackenberg
• Fred Kappler: Group sales leader, replaces Christian Klingler
• Michael Mauer: Group design head, replaces Walter de Silva
• Wolfram Thomas: Group production chief, replaces Michael Macht
• Ralf-Gerhard Willner: Group auto architectures guru.
The number of top managers who report to Mueller is nearly half what it was before the diesel scandal broke.
On the same day the executive shakeup was announced, European Parliament voted to investigate VW’s emissions scandal and whether regulators such as the European Commission failed to prevent cheating by the auto industry in vehicle pollution tests. Claude Thames (Green member of EU Parliament) says, “It’s about private corporations organizing the largest industrial fraud ever.” Not so fast, say reps from the EU Commission; individual nations test and enforce pollution rules.
Time magazine’s year-end roundup says: VW’s flaunting of diesel emissions standards is the low point in its list of issues that drove the news. Three months after the public learned of VW’s malfeasance, the German firm still hasn’t presented a clear remedy for its dirty 2.0-liter TDI engines sold in the U.S. It’s already developed and received approval for a European market fix-it plan, but for the U.S. all we know is that VW presented something to the EPA on Nov. 20.
Since revelation of VW’s scam, a series of admissions and blunders by the people-car firm has further tarnished its image, upended its management, angered dealers and confused consumers. I’ll take you on a tour of what’s unfolded since your last Autoist.
Early November: The EPA found fault with the Audi-developed 3.0-liter V-6 diesel (TDI) affecting some 80,000 Audi, Porsche and VW models sold in the U.S. That’s the Touareg’s mighty diesel. VW/Audi initially claimed this mill didn’t have emissions cheating software, but later changed its tune when it evaluated the EPA’s evidence.
While this diesel engine doesn’t have the same emission-skirting software that’s at the center of the 2.0-liter diesel fiasco, it has a defeat-like program. That software is part of the engine’s temperature-conditioning mode. It adjusts catalytic converter temperature. It also impacts NOx, but its engineering goal is less nefarious; Audi wanted to ensure that the emissions system sensors and other components worked and kept working. VW/Audi issued a stop-sell order.
Weeks later, VW/Audi proposed fixes: it will properly document its emission control software to comply with EPA rules. It will also recall affected vehicles for a software update.
•TROUBLE: VW’S CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS BLUNDER: In early November, VW revealed yet another wrinkle. In addition to its dirty diesels’ NOx woes, 800,000 European diesel and gas-powered vehicles built by several of its brands had “implausible” mpg figures. They produced more carbon dioxide emissions than VW claimed. Because CO2 emissions are directly tied to fuel consumption, VW admitted yet another snafu. It didn’t properly conduct European-market fuel-economy certification tests.
A month later, CEO Mueller claimed the CO2 emissions situation was less serious than thought. Further examination showed that only 36,000 vehicles spanning nine models were at odds with EU mandates. One affected machine: the 2.0-liter TDI Golf convertible with five-speed manual. Another: the three-cylinder 1.0-liter TSI Polo BlueMotion.
•SORRY: VW’S ENGINEERS COULDN’T MEET U.S. NOX RULES, CHOSE DECEPTION: On Dec. 10 in Wolfsburg, VW chairman Hans Dieter Poetsch explained the origins of the firm’s emissions crises. Investigations reveal that 10 years ago a small group of unnamed engine development engineers working on the 2.0-liter TDI (EA189) mill for the U.S. market could not comply with American emissions requirements and also meet cost and timing targets.
Engineers, therefore, developed software that contained emissions strategies that produced low NOx in lab tests but produced significantly higher NOx levels for real-world driving. This was not one mistake but a series of evasive moves that breached the rules and tainted the “lean NOx trap” used on Jettas, Beetles and Golfs plus the 2012 U.S.-built Passat’s AdBlue selective catalytic reduction system. That mistake also affects VW’s new EA288 four-cylinder diesel engines introduced for 2015. Although these engines have up-to-date exhaust after-treatment systems, they were not fully utilized in an apparent move to reduce consumption of AdBlue, or urea fluid.
European authorities have accepted VW’s relatively low-cost EA 189 fixes. VW CEO Matthias Mueller says that software and hardware updates comply with European NOx goals without changing engine performance. He says you can trust his words. VW’s engineers developed an astonishingly simple device that received regulatory approval for Euro 1.6-liter diesel engines. It’s a gizmo that has everyone astonished; it looks as if VW’s engineers plucked it from a Home Depot plumbing aisle—a flow transformer. This plastic-fantastic tube with mesh improves the airflow metering system’s accuracy, assuring optimum fuel combustion. Stateside, VW is still working with authorities to solve NOx emissions violations. Mueller planned to visit the U.S. during and after the Detroit auto show in January.
Skeptics say VW’s emissions evading scheme must have involved more than a small group of engineers. Bloomberg News reports that German prosecutors are investigating whether Robert Bosch employees helped VW rig software. Previously, Bild-Zeitung reported that Bosch warned VW in a 2007 letter that the way the carmaker planned to use the software installed in diesel engines was illegal. Bosch claimed that it only supplied VW with exhaust treatment components that were standard in many cars. VWCA
Cliff Leppke | firstname.lastname@example.org
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE:
- CONVENTION 2016: The 61st Annual VWCA Convention is headed for Rockford, Ill.
- NIVA'S VW FEST: The Northeast Illinois VW Association event is a big success.
- NEW PASSAT: The revamped 2016 TSI SEL model takes motoring to the next level.
PLUS OUR REGULAR COLUMNS AND FEATURES:
- Driver's Seat - VW news & views by Cliff Leppke
- Frontdriver – Richard G. Van Treuren
- Casual Collector - Steve Mierz
- Small Talk - VW and Audi news - quickly
- Retro Autoist - From the archives
- Parting Shot - Photo feature
- VW Toon-ups - Cartoon feature by Tom Janiszewski
LOGGED-IN MEMBERS CAN SEE THE ENTIRE AUTOIST ISSUE BY CLICKING ON THE COVER PHOTO ABOVE.
Mar-May | 2017
Will VW See The Light?
VW once again evokes the memory of the beloved Microbus with its new concept called I.D. Buzz, which created quite a stir at the annual auto show in Detroit. (Photos by Tom Janiszewski)
Jan-Feb | 2017
Joe Mayer says he's not out to punish VW over its diesel scandal - he just wanted to make some extra money on a car he thought would be junked. (Photos by Joe Mayer via jalopnik.com.)
Nov-Dec | 2016
WATTS OF FUN . . . . . . Meet the new e-Golf
Here's the car that, when you give it a charge, you'll get one back. In VW's first important pivot from its diesel scandal, the e-Golf provides an opening salvo in the carmaker's goal to electrify its fleet.
Sep-Oct | 2016
61st Annual Convention
What's an anniversary without a cake? This one didn't go far or last long as Club members enjoyed a variety of activities, including a Sunday car show and picnic, part of the 61st Annual Convention.
Jul-Aug | 2016
It's Time To Show Off
A couple of Karmann Ghias are resplendent at the Michigan Vintage VW Club's Festival in Ypsilanti, Mich. The club held its 29th event in May, while Mid America Motorworks in Effingham, Ill., saluted the air-cooled crowd with a big show in June.
May-Jun | 2016
Windfall for TDI owners?
The scam was on as early as 2008, when this Candy White Jetta TDI Clean Diesel model, embellished with green plant matter, was rolled out. In case anyone had a doubt, VW added the wording "Not a concept car."
Mar-Apr | 2016
Lost In Translation
VW CEO Mattias Mueller was in the hot glare of media lights at the North American International Auto Show in Detroit, providing the company's latest response to the diesel emissions scandal.
Jan-Feb | 2016
VW's Game Plan
VW remains embroiled in a high-stakes game involving government agencies and hundreds of thousands of owners of diesel models. The company's car on the road of Life has taken a big detour.
Nov-Dec | 2015
Engine with a split personality puts VW on the hot seat
The news in September was beyond belief for many VW and TDI enthusiasts: Volkswagen executives admitted that the company intentionally produced cars that violated clean-air laws.
Sep-Oct | 2015
Big bites of fun at the 60th VWCA Convention
Doug Narczewshi from Spring Valley, IL, looks over an assortment of water-cooled VWs on display at NIVA's Bug Fest event, part of the 60th VWCA Convention in suburban Chicago.
Jul-Aug | 2015
1969 Beetle gets a second chance to adorn the silver screen
Crew members working on the film "The Good Blonde" prepare for a shot on the California coast involving a 1969 Beetle owned by VWCA member and correspondent Lois Grace.
May-Jun | 2015
My Mom, the Daredevil
Around 1960, Cliff Leppke had no idea what was in store for him while being ferried about by his mother. Needless to say, his head was up and his eyes were open.
Mar-Apr | 2015
It's Show Time!
The Northeast Illinois Volkswagen Association has an activity-packed weekend planned for the 60th VWCA Convention in suburban Chicago.
Jan-Feb | 2015
Jack Pavie of suburban Philadelphia had to wait several months to get his 1975 Rabbit diesel, one of three models he enjoyed in the '70s and '80s.
Nov-Dec | 2014
Golf Lessons: Three new models charge up hatchback lineup
The scene at the Salamander Resort in Middleburg, Va., where Cliff Leppke and other media members ran the 2015 Volkswagens through their paces.
Sep-Oct | 2014
Having fun with miles per gallon
A morning commute for a 2012 Golf TDI has become a test on how high the fuel mileage will end up. It hit a high mark in July.
In the VWCA's 59 years of Conventions, the setting in Hudson, Mich. was unique. Just ask VWCA's Tom Janiszewski, the guy driving the orange 1974 Camper.
May 25 marks the 15th anniversary of my family's New Beetle ownership experience. It was on that day in 1999 that we took delivery of a brand new red GLS model from Kempthorn Volkswagen in Canton, Ohio.
Mar-Apr | 2014
Dune buggy with a twist at the Detroit Auto Show
There's a saying that everything old is new again, and since the New Beetle's production debut in 1998, that has been the car's underlying theme.
Jan-Feb | 2014
Back At The Ranch
At northern California getaway, Vernon and his family found plenty of ways to enjoy life