2016, May - Jun
Windfall for TDI owners?
By Cliff Leppke
Diesel agreement only hints at what’s to come in June
If this were vintage daytime TV, VW’s executives would be host Monty Hall and its engineers would replace the lovely Carol Merrill standing next to boxes hiding possible pollution-control prizes. Their goal: Let’s Make a Deal with the EPA and the California Air Resources Board, which are like contestants wearing bizarre rule-making or breaking costumes.
That deal was necessary because the Justice Department had drawn an April 21 line in the sand involving about 480,000 polluting VW and Audi models powered by 2.0-liter diesel engines. And on that date, VW, the U.S. government and CARB reached an agreement with multiple moving parts: VW will buy back the affected TDIs or cancel leases, repair them and offer “substantial compensation” for the affected owners regardless of which option they choose, U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer said in San Francisco.
As part of the agreement, the judge said VW will establish a fund to address environmental damage caused by the excess nitrogen oxide emissions — up to 40 percent above the legal limit — in addition to promoting green vehicle technologies.
In a statement, VW says it “intends to compensate its customers fully and to remediate any impact on the environment from excess diesel emissions.” It added: “Volkswagen is committed to earning back the trust of its customers, dealers, regulators and the American public. These agreements in principle are an important step on the road to making things right. As noted today in court, customers in the United States do not need to take any action at this time.”
The agreement in principle only teased owners, leaving many to speculate over what they can except in payback from VW. More details will be made public after a June 21 court date. But TDI owners will have ample time to decide their cars’ fate — perhaps as much as two years. Vehicle values are considered to be fair-market numbers pre-dating the scandal. Obviously, many devils comprise the details.
About 80,000 3.0-liter V-6 diesels with VW, Porsche and Audi badges are excluded in the agreement. A resolution on those vehicles has yet to be agreed upon, and VW still faces hefty government fines for its emissions violations.
Many believe that older TDIs will be treated differently because of their original emission setups. The 2009-2014 Jetta, for instance, has a lean-burn trap, while the 2012 Passat has selective catalytic reduction or AdBlue.
So the early 2.0-liter TDI is expected to require a completely new selective catalytic reduction exhaust system. Installing that and its cost will be very high, plus there’s talk that VW has a new larger catalyst that would require body modifications to install. This is what led to the speculation that VW would rather buy back these cars.
Cars with SCR such as the Passat and 2015-and-newer TDIs, should require less fiddling. They have the current standard in diesel emission systems.
Before the agreement, CARB enforcement official Todd Sax said the board might accept an incomplete repair of the 2.0-liter TDI mills in exchange for some other form of environmental remediation. Roughly 82,000 cars are affected in California. Some other states also use CARB rules. Whether VW’s remedy doesn’t meet the oxides of nitrogen limits or the onboard diagnostics systems don’t meet specs isn’t clear.
Thus, at this juncture VW’s dirty diesel saga is far from over. But we do know that it will be the subject of at least one movie. And documentary filmmaker Steve Kalfer, a three-time Oscar nominee, is working on a VW diesel emissions crisis project called “Backfire: The Volkswagen Fraud of the Century.” Kalfer, who is also a VW dealer, says his film will present the view of the participants he interviews. He says VW’s American dealers have been hurt by the automaker’s deception, as if “they’ve been thrown in the gutter.”
Who’s getting the “zonk” — that goofy gag gift that sometimes befell “Let’s Make a Deal” contestants could be anyone who has a stake in VW’s not-clean diesel vehicles.
In Europe, VW’s 2.0-liter TDI Passat recall ground to a halt. It turns out that the fix doesn’t meet carbon dioxide rules, which in layman’s terms means the Passat TDI’s fuel economy dropped. Therefore, VW must devise another fix. Other snags include who’s doing the repair work and whether engine noise remains the same.
After setting aside $18.32 billion to fund the recall of millions of diesel cars, legal claims and related costs, VWAG posed the firm’s worst-ever operating loss of $4.65 billion for 2015. The amount set aside to cover costs related the firm’s emissions-cheating is more than double its earlier provisions and nowhere near the maximum it could face in U.S. penalties.
As ugly as it sounds, some investors see a bright spot—VW’s future fate might be better than thought. Its April 21 deal and the amount set aside, for instance, hint that VW might not face the worse-case fine scenario. VWCA
Cliff Leppke | email@example.com
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE:
- LAST CALL: Procrastinators need to get it in gear to sign up for the 2016 Convention.
- MY CAR DOES WHAT?: Website cuts through the clutter of new safety features.
- BEETLES ON PATROL: For decades, the classic Beetle helped maintain law and order.
- GOLF ALLTRACK: VW’s new compact crossover is called “practical and sporty”
PLUS OUR REGULAR COLUMNS AND FEATURES:
- Driver's Seat - VW news & views by Cliff Leppke
- Frontdriver – Richard G. Van Treuren
- Small Talk - VW and Audi news - quickly
- Retro Autoist - From the archives
- Parting Shot - Photo feature
- Local Volks Scene - A snapshot of local chapter activities
- VW Toon-ups - Cartoon feature by Tom Janiszewski
LOGGED-IN MEMBERS CAN SEE THE ENTIRE AUTOIST ISSUE BY CLICKING ON THE COVER PHOTO ABOVE.
Mar-May | 2017
Will VW See The Light?
VW once again evokes the memory of the beloved Microbus with its new concept called I.D. Buzz, which created quite a stir at the annual auto show in Detroit. (Photos by Tom Janiszewski)
Jan-Feb | 2017
Joe Mayer says he's not out to punish VW over its diesel scandal - he just wanted to make some extra money on a car he thought would be junked. (Photos by Joe Mayer via jalopnik.com.)
Nov-Dec | 2016
WATTS OF FUN . . . . . . Meet the new e-Golf
Here's the car that, when you give it a charge, you'll get one back. In VW's first important pivot from its diesel scandal, the e-Golf provides an opening salvo in the carmaker's goal to electrify its fleet.
Sep-Oct | 2016
61st Annual Convention
What's an anniversary without a cake? This one didn't go far or last long as Club members enjoyed a variety of activities, including a Sunday car show and picnic, part of the 61st Annual Convention.
Jul-Aug | 2016
It's Time To Show Off
A couple of Karmann Ghias are resplendent at the Michigan Vintage VW Club's Festival in Ypsilanti, Mich. The club held its 29th event in May, while Mid America Motorworks in Effingham, Ill., saluted the air-cooled crowd with a big show in June.
May-Jun | 2016
Windfall for TDI owners?
The scam was on as early as 2008, when this Candy White Jetta TDI Clean Diesel model, embellished with green plant matter, was rolled out. In case anyone had a doubt, VW added the wording "Not a concept car."
Mar-Apr | 2016
Lost In Translation
VW CEO Mattias Mueller was in the hot glare of media lights at the North American International Auto Show in Detroit, providing the company's latest response to the diesel emissions scandal.
Jan-Feb | 2016
VW's Game Plan
VW remains embroiled in a high-stakes game involving government agencies and hundreds of thousands of owners of diesel models. The company's car on the road of Life has taken a big detour.
Nov-Dec | 2015
Engine with a split personality puts VW on the hot seat
The news in September was beyond belief for many VW and TDI enthusiasts: Volkswagen executives admitted that the company intentionally produced cars that violated clean-air laws.
Sep-Oct | 2015
Big bites of fun at the 60th VWCA Convention
Doug Narczewshi from Spring Valley, IL, looks over an assortment of water-cooled VWs on display at NIVA's Bug Fest event, part of the 60th VWCA Convention in suburban Chicago.
Jul-Aug | 2015
1969 Beetle gets a second chance to adorn the silver screen
Crew members working on the film "The Good Blonde" prepare for a shot on the California coast involving a 1969 Beetle owned by VWCA member and correspondent Lois Grace.
May-Jun | 2015
My Mom, the Daredevil
Around 1960, Cliff Leppke had no idea what was in store for him while being ferried about by his mother. Needless to say, his head was up and his eyes were open.
Mar-Apr | 2015
It's Show Time!
The Northeast Illinois Volkswagen Association has an activity-packed weekend planned for the 60th VWCA Convention in suburban Chicago.
Jan-Feb | 2015
Jack Pavie of suburban Philadelphia had to wait several months to get his 1975 Rabbit diesel, one of three models he enjoyed in the '70s and '80s.
Nov-Dec | 2014
Golf Lessons: Three new models charge up hatchback lineup
The scene at the Salamander Resort in Middleburg, Va., where Cliff Leppke and other media members ran the 2015 Volkswagens through their paces.
Sep-Oct | 2014
Having fun with miles per gallon
A morning commute for a 2012 Golf TDI has become a test on how high the fuel mileage will end up. It hit a high mark in July.
In the VWCA's 59 years of Conventions, the setting in Hudson, Mich. was unique. Just ask VWCA's Tom Janiszewski, the guy driving the orange 1974 Camper.
May 25 marks the 15th anniversary of my family's New Beetle ownership experience. It was on that day in 1999 that we took delivery of a brand new red GLS model from Kempthorn Volkswagen in Canton, Ohio.
Mar-Apr | 2014
Dune buggy with a twist at the Detroit Auto Show
There's a saying that everything old is new again, and since the New Beetle's production debut in 1998, that has been the car's underlying theme.
Jan-Feb | 2014
Back At The Ranch
At northern California getaway, Vernon and his family found plenty of ways to enjoy life